| blob | 3a439e4f2f946175e2cb2e6c777bbad723c2c683 |
2 Differences in borders between Excel and LibreOffice Calc.
4 The sources for this Document is:
5 - sc/qa/unit/data/ods/test_borders_export.ods (new Test-Document)
6 - sc/qa/unit/subsequent_export-test.cxx (ScExportTest::testBordersExchangeXLSX)
8 - sc/source/filter/excel/xestyle.cxx (void lclGetBorderLine)
9 - sc/source/filter/oox/stylesbuffer.cxx (Border::convertBorderLine)
11 Bug-Ticket: tdf#79787
14 In LibreOffice the lines are defined by two information: the style and the width of the line. There are seven different line styles available. And the following line width can be selected: 0.05 pt, 0.25 pt, 0.50 pt, 0.75 pt, 1.0 pt, 1.25 pt, 1.50 pt, … until 9pt.
15 In Excel you can only define the style of the line. There are 13 different styles available. The width cannot be entered explicitly, instead you have different styles for a solid line with different width (s. Screenshots below).
16 The question is now: how to map the borderlines of LibreOffice to Excel and vice versa.
17 In the overview below you can see the mapping as it is and some suggestions how to improve it. As the borders are defined different, it will not be possible to define a 1:1 mapping."
19 The current mapping is mainly defined of the width, but i think better is the line-style, i think user see that first
21 Base for the evaluation is LibreOffice master (commit [bbfeab3b13b48c99cfa2f94c8c34bc3efef7faa9] ) and Excel 2013
23 EXCEL || LIBREOFFICE
24 Excel-Line Name Value || LO-Line Name Value
25 None EXC_LINE_NONE 0 || none table::BorderLineStyle::NONE 32767 (-1)
26 1 EXC_LINE_HAIR 7 || 1 table::BorderLineStyle::SOLID 0
27 2 EXC_LINE_DOTTED 4 || 2 table::BorderLineStyle::DOTTED 1
28 3 EXC_LINE_THIN_DASHDOTDOT 11 || 3 table::BorderLineStyle::DASHED 2
29 4 EXC_LINE_THIN_DASHDOT 9 || 4 table::BorderLineStyle::FINE_DASHED 14
30 5 EXC_LINE_DASHED 3 || 5 table::BorderLineStyle::DASH_DOT 16
31 6 EXC_LINE_THIN 1 || 6 table::BorderLineStyle::DASH_DOT_DOT 17
32 7 EXC_LINE_MEDIUM_DASHDOTDOT 12 || 7 table::BorderLineStyle::DOUBLE_THIN 15
33 8 EXC_LINE_MEDIUM_SLANT_DASHDOT 13 ||
34 9 EXC_LINE_MEDIUM_DASHDOT 10 ||
35 10 EXC_LINE_MEDIUM_DASHED 8 ||
36 11 EXC_LINE_MEDIUM 2 ||
37 12 EXC_LINE_THICK 5 ||
38 13 EXC_LINE_DOUBLE 6 ||
40 In the following cases a 1:1 mapping is not possible.
42 Excel -> LibreOffice: Create in Excel and open it in LibreOffice. || LibreOffice -> Excel: Create Sheet in LibreOffice and save as XLSX.
43 Create in| In Excel save as XLSX, | In Excel save as ODS,|| Created in | Load saved xlsx-file | Load saved xlsx-file
44 Excel2013| Load in LibreOffice | Load in LibreOffice ||LibreOffice with | in LibreOffice | in Excel
45 _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
46 Line |current transformation|new suggestion|current transformation||Line Width |current transformation|new suggestion|current|new suggestion
47 | Line Width | Line Width | Line Width || | Line Width | Line Width | Line | Line
48 13 | 7 2,50 | 7 1,75 | 1 0,05 || 2 0,05 - 0,5| 1 0,05 | 2 0,75 | 6 | 2
49 || 2 1,75 - 2,2| 1 1,75 | 4 1,75 | 6 | 8
50 || 2 2,50 - 9,0| 1 2,50 | 4 1,75 | 6 | 8
51 || 3 0,05 - 0,5| 1 0,05 | 2 0,75 | 6 | 2
52 || 3 0,75 - 1,5| 4 0,75 | 4 0,75 | 5 | 5
53 || 3 2,50 - 9,0| 1 2,50 | 3 1,75 | 6 | 10
54 || 4 0,05 - 0,5| 1 0,05 | 4 0,75 | 6 | 5
55 || 4 2,50 - 9,0| 1 2,50 | 4 1,75 | 6 | 8
56 || 5 0,05 - 0,5| 1 0,05 | 4 0,75 | 6 | 5
57 || 5 2,50 - 9,0| 1 2,50 | 5 1,75 | 6 | 9
58 || 6 0,05 - 0,5| 1 0,05 | 4 0,75 | 6 | 5
59 || 6 2,50 - 9,0| 1 2,50 | 6 1,75 | 6 | 7
60 || 7 0,05 - 9,0| 7 2,50 | 7 1,75 | 13 | 13
63 No similar border available => choose one that is not used similar one and make the roundtrip via xlsx-file possible (create in LO, save as xlsx, open in LO and
64 border is not changed)
66 Excel -> LibreOffice: Create in Excel and open it in LibreOffice. || LibreOffice -> Excel: Create Sheet in LibreOffice and save as XLSX.
67 Create in| In Excel save as XLSX, | In Excel save as ODS,|| Created in | Load saved xlsx-file | Load saved xlsx-file
68 Excel2013| Load in LibreOffice | Load in LibreOffice ||LibreOffice with | in LibreOffice | in Excel
69 _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
70 Line |current transformation|new suggestion|current transformation||Line Width |current transformation|new suggestion|current|new suggestion
71 | Line Width | Line Width | Line Width || | Line Width | Line Width | Line | Line
72 8 | 5 1,75 | 4 1,75 | 1 0,05 || 4 1,75 - 2,2| 1 1,75 | 4 1,75 | 6 | 8
75 In the following cases the mapping is o.k. and should not be changed.
77 Excel -> LibreOffice: Create in Excel and open it in LibreOffice. || LibreOffice -> Excel: Create Sheet in LibreOffice and save as XLSX.
78 Create in| In Excel save as XLSX, | In Excel save as ODS,|| Created in | Load saved xlsx-file | Load saved xlsx-file
79 Excel2013| Load in LibreOffice | Load in LibreOffice ||LibreOffice with | in LibreOffice | in Excel
80 _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
81 Line |current transformation|new suggestion|current transformation||Line Width |current transformation |current
82 | Line Width | Line Width | Line Width || | Line Width | Line
83 1 | 1 0,05 | 1 0,05 | 1 0,05 || 1 0,05 - 0,5| 1 0,05 | 1
84 2 | 2 0,75 | 2 0,75 | 1 0,05 || 1 0,75 - 1,5| 1 0,75 | 6
85 3 | 6 0,75 | 6 0,75 | 1 0,05 || 1 1,75 - 2,2| 1 1,75 | 11
86 4 | 5 0,75 | 5 0,75 | 1 0,05 || 1 2,50 - 9,0| 1 2,50 | 12
87 5 | 4 0,75 | 4 0,75 | 1 0,05 || 2 0,75 - 1,5| 2 0,75 | 2
88 6 | 1 0,75 | 1 0,75 | 1 0,05 || 3 1,75 - 2,2| 3 1,75 | 10
89 7 | 6 1,75 | 6 1,75 | 1 0,05 || 4 0,75 - 1,5| 4 0,75 | 5
90 9 | 5 1,75 | 5 1,75 | 1 0,05 || 5 0,75 - 1,5| 5 0,75 | 4
91 10 | 3 1,75 | 3 1,75 | 3 2,00 || 5 1,75 - 2,2| 5 1,75 | 9
92 11 | 1 1,75 | 1 1,75 | 1 2,00 || 6 0,75 - 1,5| 6 0,75 | 3
93 12 | 1 2,50 | 1 2,50 | 1 2,50 || 6 1,75 - 2,2| 6 1,75 | 7