4 * Takes tokens makes them well-formed (balance end tags, etc.)
6 * Specification of the armor attributes this strategy uses:
8 * - MakeWellFormed_TagClosedError: This armor field is used to
9 * suppress tag closed errors for certain tokens [TagClosedSuppress],
10 * in particular, if a tag was generated automatically by HTML
11 * Purifier, we may rely on our infrastructure to close it for us
12 * and shouldn't report an error to the user [TagClosedAuto].
14 class HTMLPurifier_Strategy_MakeWellFormed
extends HTMLPurifier_Strategy
18 * Array stream of tokens being processed.
19 * @type HTMLPurifier_Token[]
25 * @type HTMLPurifier_Token
30 * Zipper managing the true state.
31 * @type HTMLPurifier_Zipper
36 * Current nesting of elements.
42 * Injectors active in this stream processing.
43 * @type HTMLPurifier_Injector[]
48 * Current instance of HTMLPurifier_Config.
49 * @type HTMLPurifier_Config
54 * Current instance of HTMLPurifier_Context.
55 * @type HTMLPurifier_Context
60 * @param HTMLPurifier_Token[] $tokens
61 * @param HTMLPurifier_Config $config
62 * @param HTMLPurifier_Context $context
63 * @return HTMLPurifier_Token[]
64 * @throws HTMLPurifier_Exception
66 public function execute($tokens, $config, $context)
68 $definition = $config->getHTMLDefinition();
71 $generator = new HTMLPurifier_Generator($config, $context);
72 $escape_invalid_tags = $config->get('Core.EscapeInvalidTags');
73 // used for autoclose early abortion
74 $global_parent_allowed_elements = $definition->info_parent_def
->child
->getAllowedElements($config);
75 $e = $context->get('ErrorCollector', true);
76 $i = false; // injector index
77 list($zipper, $token) = HTMLPurifier_Zipper
::fromArray($tokens);
78 if ($token === NULL) {
81 $reprocess = false; // whether or not to reprocess the same token
85 $this->stack
=& $stack;
86 $this->tokens
=& $tokens;
87 $this->token
=& $token;
88 $this->zipper
=& $zipper;
89 $this->config
= $config;
90 $this->context
= $context;
93 $context->register('CurrentNesting', $stack);
94 $context->register('InputZipper', $zipper);
95 $context->register('CurrentToken', $token);
97 // -- begin INJECTOR --
99 $this->injectors
= array();
101 $injectors = $config->getBatch('AutoFormat');
102 $def_injectors = $definition->info_injector
;
103 $custom_injectors = $injectors['Custom'];
104 unset($injectors['Custom']); // special case
105 foreach ($injectors as $injector => $b) {
106 // XXX: Fix with a legitimate lookup table of enabled filters
107 if (strpos($injector, '.') !== false) {
110 $injector = "HTMLPurifier_Injector_$injector";
114 $this->injectors
[] = new $injector;
116 foreach ($def_injectors as $injector) {
117 // assumed to be objects
118 $this->injectors
[] = $injector;
120 foreach ($custom_injectors as $injector) {
124 if (is_string($injector)) {
125 $injector = "HTMLPurifier_Injector_$injector";
126 $injector = new $injector;
128 $this->injectors
[] = $injector;
131 // give the injectors references to the definition and context
132 // variables for performance reasons
133 foreach ($this->injectors
as $ix => $injector) {
134 $error = $injector->prepare($config, $context);
138 array_splice($this->injectors
, $ix, 1); // rm the injector
139 trigger_error("Cannot enable {$injector->name} injector because $error is not allowed", E_USER_WARNING
);
142 // -- end INJECTOR --
144 // a note on reprocessing:
145 // In order to reduce code duplication, whenever some code needs
146 // to make HTML changes in order to make things "correct", the
147 // new HTML gets sent through the purifier, regardless of its
148 // status. This means that if we add a start token, because it
149 // was totally necessary, we don't have to update nesting; we just
150 // punt ($reprocess = true; continue;) and it does that for us.
152 // isset is in loop because $tokens size changes during loop exec
154 // only increment if we don't need to reprocess
155 $reprocess ?
$reprocess = false : $token = $zipper->next($token)) {
157 // check for a rewind
159 // possibility: disable rewinding if the current token has a
160 // rewind set on it already. This would offer protection from
161 // infinite loop, but might hinder some advanced rewinding.
162 $rewind_offset = $this->injectors
[$i]->getRewindOffset();
163 if (is_int($rewind_offset)) {
164 for ($j = 0; $j < $rewind_offset; $j++
) {
165 if (empty($zipper->front
)) break;
166 $token = $zipper->prev($token);
167 // indicate that other injectors should not process this token,
168 // but we need to reprocess it. See Note [Injector skips]
169 unset($token->skip
[$i]);
171 if ($token instanceof HTMLPurifier_Token_Start
) {
172 array_pop($this->stack
);
173 } elseif ($token instanceof HTMLPurifier_Token_End
) {
174 $this->stack
[] = $token->start
;
181 // handle case of document end
182 if ($token === NULL) {
183 // kill processing if stack is empty
184 if (empty($this->stack
)) {
189 $top_nesting = array_pop($this->stack
);
190 $this->stack
[] = $top_nesting;
192 // send error [TagClosedSuppress]
193 if ($e && !isset($top_nesting->armor
['MakeWellFormed_TagClosedError'])) {
194 $e->send(E_NOTICE
, 'Strategy_MakeWellFormed: Tag closed by document end', $top_nesting);
197 // append, don't splice, since this is the end
198 $token = new HTMLPurifier_Token_End($top_nesting->name
);
205 //echo '<br>'; printZipper($zipper, $token);//printTokens($this->stack);
208 // quick-check: if it's not a tag, no need to process
209 if (empty($token->is_tag
)) {
210 if ($token instanceof HTMLPurifier_Token_Text
) {
211 foreach ($this->injectors
as $i => $injector) {
212 if (isset($token->skip
[$i])) {
213 // See Note [Injector skips]
216 if ($token->rewind
!== null && $token->rewind
!== $i) {
221 $injector->handleText($r);
222 $token = $this->processToken($r, $i);
227 // another possibility is a comment
231 if (isset($definition->info
[$token->name
])) {
232 $type = $definition->info
[$token->name
]->child
->type
;
234 $type = false; // Type is unknown, treat accordingly
237 // quick tag checks: anything that's *not* an end tag
239 if ($type === 'empty' && $token instanceof HTMLPurifier_Token_Start
) {
240 // claims to be a start tag but is empty
241 $token = new HTMLPurifier_Token_Empty(
249 } elseif ($type && $type !== 'empty' && $token instanceof HTMLPurifier_Token_Empty
) {
250 // claims to be empty but really is a start tag
251 // NB: this assignment is required
253 $token = new HTMLPurifier_Token_End($token->name
);
254 $token = $this->insertBefore(
255 new HTMLPurifier_Token_Start($old_token->name
, $old_token->attr
, $old_token->line
, $old_token->col
, $old_token->armor
)
257 // punt (since we had to modify the input stream in a non-trivial way)
260 } elseif ($token instanceof HTMLPurifier_Token_Empty
) {
263 } elseif ($token instanceof HTMLPurifier_Token_Start
) {
266 // ...unless they also have to close their parent
267 if (!empty($this->stack
)) {
269 // Performance note: you might think that it's rather
270 // inefficient, recalculating the autoclose information
271 // for every tag that a token closes (since when we
272 // do an autoclose, we push a new token into the
273 // stream and then /process/ that, before
274 // re-processing this token.) But this is
275 // necessary, because an injector can make an
276 // arbitrary transformations to the autoclosing
277 // tokens we introduce, so things may have changed
278 // in the meantime. Also, doing the inefficient thing is
279 // "easy" to reason about (for certain perverse definitions
282 $parent = array_pop($this->stack
);
283 $this->stack
[] = $parent;
286 $parent_elements = null;
288 if (isset($definition->info
[$parent->name
])) {
289 $parent_def = $definition->info
[$parent->name
];
290 $parent_elements = $parent_def->child
->getAllowedElements($config);
291 $autoclose = !isset($parent_elements[$token->name
]);
294 if ($autoclose && $definition->info
[$token->name
]->wrap
) {
295 // Check if an element can be wrapped by another
296 // element to make it valid in a context (for
297 // example, <ul><ul> needs a <li> in between)
298 $wrapname = $definition->info
[$token->name
]->wrap
;
299 $wrapdef = $definition->info
[$wrapname];
300 $elements = $wrapdef->child
->getAllowedElements($config);
301 if (isset($elements[$token->name
]) && isset($parent_elements[$wrapname])) {
302 $newtoken = new HTMLPurifier_Token_Start($wrapname);
303 $token = $this->insertBefore($newtoken);
310 if ($autoclose && $parent_def->formatting
) {
315 // check if this autoclose is doomed to fail
316 // (this rechecks $parent, which his harmless)
317 $autoclose_ok = isset($global_parent_allowed_elements[$token->name
]);
318 if (!$autoclose_ok) {
319 foreach ($this->stack
as $ancestor) {
320 $elements = $definition->info
[$ancestor->name
]->child
->getAllowedElements($config);
321 if (isset($elements[$token->name
])) {
322 $autoclose_ok = true;
325 if ($definition->info
[$token->name
]->wrap
) {
326 $wrapname = $definition->info
[$token->name
]->wrap
;
327 $wrapdef = $definition->info
[$wrapname];
328 $wrap_elements = $wrapdef->child
->getAllowedElements($config);
329 if (isset($wrap_elements[$token->name
]) && isset($elements[$wrapname])) {
330 $autoclose_ok = true;
337 // errors need to be updated
338 $new_token = new HTMLPurifier_Token_End($parent->name
);
339 $new_token->start
= $parent;
340 // [TagClosedSuppress]
341 if ($e && !isset($parent->armor
['MakeWellFormed_TagClosedError'])) {
343 $e->send(E_NOTICE
, 'Strategy_MakeWellFormed: Tag auto closed', $parent);
345 $e->send(E_NOTICE
, 'Strategy_MakeWellFormed: Tag carryover', $parent);
349 $element = clone $parent;
351 $element->armor
['MakeWellFormed_TagClosedError'] = true;
352 $element->carryover
= true;
353 $token = $this->processToken(array($new_token, $token, $element));
355 $token = $this->insertBefore($new_token);
358 $token = $this->remove();
369 foreach ($this->injectors
as $i => $injector) {
370 if (isset($token->skip
[$i])) {
371 // See Note [Injector skips]
374 if ($token->rewind
!== null && $token->rewind
!== $i) {
378 $injector->handleElement($r);
379 $token = $this->processToken($r, $i);
384 // ah, nothing interesting happened; do normal processing
385 if ($token instanceof HTMLPurifier_Token_Start
) {
386 $this->stack
[] = $token;
387 } elseif ($token instanceof HTMLPurifier_Token_End
) {
388 throw new HTMLPurifier_Exception(
389 'Improper handling of end tag in start code; possible error in MakeWellFormed'
396 // sanity check: we should be dealing with a closing tag
397 if (!$token instanceof HTMLPurifier_Token_End
) {
398 throw new HTMLPurifier_Exception('Unaccounted for tag token in input stream, bug in HTML Purifier');
401 // make sure that we have something open
402 if (empty($this->stack
)) {
403 if ($escape_invalid_tags) {
405 $e->send(E_WARNING
, 'Strategy_MakeWellFormed: Unnecessary end tag to text');
407 $token = new HTMLPurifier_Token_Text($generator->generateFromToken($token));
410 $e->send(E_WARNING
, 'Strategy_MakeWellFormed: Unnecessary end tag removed');
412 $token = $this->remove();
418 // first, check for the simplest case: everything closes neatly.
419 // Eventually, everything passes through here; if there are problems
420 // we modify the input stream accordingly and then punt, so that
421 // the tokens get processed again.
422 $current_parent = array_pop($this->stack
);
423 if ($current_parent->name
== $token->name
) {
424 $token->start
= $current_parent;
425 foreach ($this->injectors
as $i => $injector) {
426 if (isset($token->skip
[$i])) {
427 // See Note [Injector skips]
430 if ($token->rewind
!== null && $token->rewind
!== $i) {
434 $injector->handleEnd($r);
435 $token = $this->processToken($r, $i);
436 $this->stack
[] = $current_parent;
443 // okay, so we're trying to close the wrong tag
445 // undo the pop previous pop
446 $this->stack
[] = $current_parent;
448 // scroll back the entire nest, trying to find our tag.
449 // (feature could be to specify how far you'd like to go)
450 $size = count($this->stack
);
451 // -2 because -1 is the last element, but we already checked that
452 $skipped_tags = false;
453 for ($j = $size - 2; $j >= 0; $j--) {
454 if ($this->stack
[$j]->name
== $token->name
) {
455 $skipped_tags = array_slice($this->stack
, $j);
460 // we didn't find the tag, so remove
461 if ($skipped_tags === false) {
462 if ($escape_invalid_tags) {
464 $e->send(E_WARNING
, 'Strategy_MakeWellFormed: Stray end tag to text');
466 $token = new HTMLPurifier_Token_Text($generator->generateFromToken($token));
469 $e->send(E_WARNING
, 'Strategy_MakeWellFormed: Stray end tag removed');
471 $token = $this->remove();
477 // do errors, in REVERSE $j order: a,b,c with </a></b></c>
478 $c = count($skipped_tags);
480 for ($j = $c - 1; $j > 0; $j--) {
481 // notice we exclude $j == 0, i.e. the current ending tag, from
482 // the errors... [TagClosedSuppress]
483 if (!isset($skipped_tags[$j]->armor
['MakeWellFormed_TagClosedError'])) {
484 $e->send(E_NOTICE
, 'Strategy_MakeWellFormed: Tag closed by element end', $skipped_tags[$j]);
489 // insert tags, in FORWARD $j order: c,b,a with </a></b></c>
490 $replace = array($token);
491 for ($j = 1; $j < $c; $j++
) {
492 // ...as well as from the insertions
493 $new_token = new HTMLPurifier_Token_End($skipped_tags[$j]->name
);
494 $new_token->start
= $skipped_tags[$j];
495 array_unshift($replace, $new_token);
496 if (isset($definition->info
[$new_token->name
]) && $definition->info
[$new_token->name
]->formatting
) {
498 $element = clone $skipped_tags[$j];
499 $element->carryover
= true;
500 $element->armor
['MakeWellFormed_TagClosedError'] = true;
501 $replace[] = $element;
504 $token = $this->processToken($replace);
509 $context->destroy('CurrentToken');
510 $context->destroy('CurrentNesting');
511 $context->destroy('InputZipper');
513 unset($this->injectors
, $this->stack
, $this->tokens
);
514 return $zipper->toArray($token);
518 * Processes arbitrary token values for complicated substitution patterns.
521 * If $token is an array, it is a list of tokens to substitute for the
522 * current token. These tokens then get individually processed. If there
523 * is a leading integer in the list, that integer determines how many
524 * tokens from the stream should be removed.
526 * If $token is a regular token, it is swapped with the current token.
528 * If $token is false, the current token is deleted.
530 * If $token is an integer, that number of tokens (with the first token
531 * being the current one) will be deleted.
533 * @param HTMLPurifier_Token|array|int|bool $token Token substitution value
534 * @param HTMLPurifier_Injector|int $injector Injector that performed the substitution; default is if
535 * this is not an injector related operation.
536 * @throws HTMLPurifier_Exception
538 protected function processToken($token, $injector = -1)
540 // Zend OpCache miscompiles $token = array($token), so
541 // avoid this pattern. See: https://github.com/ezyang/htmlpurifier/issues/108
543 // normalize forms of token
544 if (is_object($token)) {
546 $token = array(1, $tmp);
548 if (is_int($token)) {
550 $token = array($tmp);
552 if ($token === false) {
555 if (!is_array($token)) {
556 throw new HTMLPurifier_Exception('Invalid token type from injector');
558 if (!is_int($token[0])) {
559 array_unshift($token, 1);
561 if ($token[0] === 0) {
562 throw new HTMLPurifier_Exception('Deleting zero tokens is not valid');
565 // $token is now an array with the following form:
566 // array(number nodes to delete, new node 1, new node 2, ...)
568 $delete = array_shift($token);
569 list($old, $r) = $this->zipper
->splice($this->token
, $delete, $token);
571 if ($injector > -1) {
572 // See Note [Injector skips]
573 // Determine appropriate skips. Here's what the code does:
574 // *If* we deleted one or more tokens, copy the skips
575 // of those tokens into the skips of the new tokens (in $token).
576 // Also, mark the newly inserted tokens as having come from
578 $oldskip = isset($old[0]) ?
$old[0]->skip
: array();
579 foreach ($token as $object) {
580 $object->skip
= $oldskip;
581 $object->skip
[$injector] = true;
590 * Inserts a token before the current token. Cursor now points to
591 * this token. You must reprocess after this.
592 * @param HTMLPurifier_Token $token
594 private function insertBefore($token)
596 // NB not $this->zipper->insertBefore(), due to positioning
598 $splice = $this->zipper
->splice($this->token
, 0, array($token));
604 * Removes current token. Cursor now points to new token occupying previously
605 * occupied space. You must reprocess after this.
607 private function remove()
609 return $this->zipper
->delete();
613 // Note [Injector skips]
614 // ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
615 // When I originally designed this class, the idea behind the 'skip'
616 // property of HTMLPurifier_Token was to help avoid infinite loops
617 // in injector processing. For example, suppose you wrote an injector
618 // that bolded swear words. Naively, you might write it so that
619 // whenever you saw ****, you replaced it with <strong>****</strong>.
621 // When this happens, we will reprocess all of the tokens with the
622 // other injectors. Now there is an opportunity for infinite loop:
623 // if we rerun the swear-word injector on these tokens, we might
624 // see **** and then reprocess again to get
625 // <strong><strong>****</strong></strong> ad infinitum.
627 // Thus, the idea of a skip is that once we process a token with
628 // an injector, we mark all of those tokens as having "come from"
629 // the injector, and we never run the injector again on these
632 // There were two more complications, however:
634 // - With HTMLPurifier_Injector_RemoveEmpty, we noticed that if
635 // you had <b><i></i></b>, after you removed the <i></i>, you
636 // really would like this injector to go back and reprocess
637 // the <b> tag, discovering that it is now empty and can be
638 // removed. So we reintroduced the possibility of infinite looping
639 // by adding a "rewind" function, which let you go back to an
640 // earlier point in the token stream and reprocess it with injectors.
641 // Needless to say, we need to UN-skip the token so it gets
644 // - Suppose that you successfuly process a token, replace it with
645 // one with your skip mark, but now another injector wants to
646 // process the skipped token with another token. Should you continue
647 // to skip that new token, or reprocess it? If you reprocess,
648 // you can end up with an infinite loop where one injector converts
649 // <a> to <b>, and then another injector converts it back. So
650 // we inherit the skips, but for some reason, I thought that we
651 // should inherit the skip from the first token of the token
652 // that we deleted. Why? Well, it seems to work OK.
654 // If I were to redesign this functionality, I would absolutely not
655 // go about doing it this way: the semantics are just not very well
656 // defined, and in any case you probably wanted to operate on trees,
657 // not token streams.
659 // vim: et sw=4 sts=4