1 //===- RSProfiling.cpp - Various profiling using random sampling ----------===//
3 // The LLVM Compiler Infrastructure
5 // This file is distributed under the University of Illinois Open Source
6 // License. See LICENSE.TXT for details.
8 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
10 // These passes implement a random sampling based profiling. Different methods
11 // of choosing when to sample are supported, as well as different types of
12 // profiling. This is done as two passes. The first is a sequence of profiling
13 // passes which insert profiling into the program, and remember what they
16 // The second stage duplicates all instructions in a function, ignoring the
17 // profiling code, then connects the two versions togeather at the entry and at
18 // backedges. At each connection point a choice is made as to whether to jump
19 // to the profiled code (take a sample) or execute the unprofiled code.
21 // It is highly recommended that after this pass one runs mem2reg and adce
22 // (instcombine load-vn gdce dse also are good to run afterwards)
24 // This design is intended to make the profiling passes independent of the RS
25 // framework, but any profiling pass that implements the RSProfiling interface
26 // is compatible with the rs framework (and thus can be sampled)
28 // TODO: obviously the block and function profiling are almost identical to the
29 // existing ones, so they can be unified (esp since these passes are valid
30 // without the rs framework).
31 // TODO: Fix choice code so that frequency is not hard coded
33 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
35 #include "llvm/Pass.h"
36 #include "llvm/Module.h"
37 #include "llvm/Instructions.h"
38 #include "llvm/Constants.h"
39 #include "llvm/DerivedTypes.h"
40 #include "llvm/Intrinsics.h"
41 #include "llvm/Transforms/Scalar.h"
42 #include "llvm/Transforms/Utils/BasicBlockUtils.h"
43 #include "llvm/Support/CommandLine.h"
44 #include "llvm/Support/Compiler.h"
45 #include "llvm/Support/Debug.h"
46 #include "llvm/Transforms/Instrumentation.h"
47 #include "RSProfiling.h"
59 static cl::opt
<RandomMeth
> RandomMethod("profile-randomness",
60 cl::desc("How to randomly choose to profile:"),
62 clEnumValN(GBV
, "global", "global counter"),
63 clEnumValN(GBVO
, "ra_global",
64 "register allocated global counter"),
65 clEnumValN(HOSTCC
, "rdcc", "cycle counter"),
69 /// NullProfilerRS - The basic profiler that does nothing. It is the default
70 /// profiler and thus terminates RSProfiler chains. It is useful for
71 /// measuring framework overhead
72 class VISIBILITY_HIDDEN NullProfilerRS
: public RSProfilers
{
74 static char ID
; // Pass identification, replacement for typeid
75 bool isProfiling(Value
* v
) {
78 bool runOnModule(Module
&M
) {
81 void getAnalysisUsage(AnalysisUsage
&AU
) const {
87 static RegisterAnalysisGroup
<RSProfilers
> A("Profiling passes");
88 static RegisterPass
<NullProfilerRS
> NP("insert-null-profiling-rs",
89 "Measure profiling framework overhead");
90 static RegisterAnalysisGroup
<RSProfilers
, true> NPT(NP
);
93 /// Chooser - Something that chooses when to make a sample of the profiled code
94 class VISIBILITY_HIDDEN Chooser
{
96 /// ProcessChoicePoint - is called for each basic block inserted to choose
97 /// between normal and sample code
98 virtual void ProcessChoicePoint(BasicBlock
*) = 0;
99 /// PrepFunction - is called once per function before other work is done.
100 /// This gives the opertunity to insert new allocas and such.
101 virtual void PrepFunction(Function
*) = 0;
102 virtual ~Chooser() {}
105 //Things that implement sampling policies
106 //A global value that is read-mod-stored to choose when to sample.
107 //A sample is taken when the global counter hits 0
108 class VISIBILITY_HIDDEN GlobalRandomCounter
: public Chooser
{
109 GlobalVariable
* Counter
;
113 GlobalRandomCounter(Module
& M
, const Type
* t
, uint64_t resetval
);
114 virtual ~GlobalRandomCounter();
115 virtual void PrepFunction(Function
* F
);
116 virtual void ProcessChoicePoint(BasicBlock
* bb
);
119 //Same is GRC, but allow register allocation of the global counter
120 class VISIBILITY_HIDDEN GlobalRandomCounterOpt
: public Chooser
{
121 GlobalVariable
* Counter
;
126 GlobalRandomCounterOpt(Module
& M
, const Type
* t
, uint64_t resetval
);
127 virtual ~GlobalRandomCounterOpt();
128 virtual void PrepFunction(Function
* F
);
129 virtual void ProcessChoicePoint(BasicBlock
* bb
);
132 //Use the cycle counter intrinsic as a source of pseudo randomness when
133 //deciding when to sample.
134 class VISIBILITY_HIDDEN CycleCounter
: public Chooser
{
138 CycleCounter(Module
& m
, uint64_t resetmask
);
139 virtual ~CycleCounter();
140 virtual void PrepFunction(Function
* F
);
141 virtual void ProcessChoicePoint(BasicBlock
* bb
);
144 /// ProfilerRS - Insert the random sampling framework
145 struct VISIBILITY_HIDDEN ProfilerRS
: public FunctionPass
{
146 static char ID
; // Pass identification, replacement for typeid
147 ProfilerRS() : FunctionPass(&ID
) {}
149 std::map
<Value
*, Value
*> TransCache
;
150 std::set
<BasicBlock
*> ChoicePoints
;
153 //Translate and duplicate values for the new profile free version of stuff
154 Value
* Translate(Value
* v
);
155 //Duplicate an entire function (with out profiling)
156 void Duplicate(Function
& F
, RSProfilers
& LI
);
157 //Called once for each backedge, handle the insertion of choice points and
158 //the interconection of the two versions of the code
159 void ProcessBackEdge(BasicBlock
* src
, BasicBlock
* dst
, Function
& F
);
160 bool runOnFunction(Function
& F
);
161 bool doInitialization(Module
&M
);
162 virtual void getAnalysisUsage(AnalysisUsage
&AU
) const;
166 static RegisterPass
<ProfilerRS
>
167 X("insert-rs-profiling-framework",
168 "Insert random sampling instrumentation framework");
170 char RSProfilers::ID
= 0;
171 char NullProfilerRS::ID
= 0;
172 char ProfilerRS::ID
= 0;
175 static void ReplacePhiPred(BasicBlock
* btarget
,
176 BasicBlock
* bold
, BasicBlock
* bnew
);
178 static void CollapsePhi(BasicBlock
* btarget
, BasicBlock
* bsrc
);
181 static void recBackEdge(BasicBlock
* bb
, T
& BackEdges
,
182 std::map
<BasicBlock
*, int>& color
,
183 std::map
<BasicBlock
*, int>& depth
,
184 std::map
<BasicBlock
*, int>& finish
,
187 //find the back edges and where they go to
189 static void getBackEdges(Function
& F
, T
& BackEdges
);
192 ///////////////////////////////////////
193 // Methods of choosing when to profile
194 ///////////////////////////////////////
196 GlobalRandomCounter::GlobalRandomCounter(Module
& M
, const Type
* t
,
197 uint64_t resetval
) : T(t
) {
198 ConstantInt
* Init
= ConstantInt::get(T
, resetval
);
200 Counter
= new GlobalVariable(T
, false, GlobalValue::InternalLinkage
,
201 Init
, "RandomSteeringCounter", &M
);
204 GlobalRandomCounter::~GlobalRandomCounter() {}
206 void GlobalRandomCounter::PrepFunction(Function
* F
) {}
208 void GlobalRandomCounter::ProcessChoicePoint(BasicBlock
* bb
) {
209 BranchInst
* t
= cast
<BranchInst
>(bb
->getTerminator());
212 LoadInst
* l
= new LoadInst(Counter
, "counter", t
);
214 ICmpInst
* s
= new ICmpInst(ICmpInst::ICMP_EQ
, l
, ConstantInt::get(T
, 0),
217 Value
* nv
= BinaryOperator::CreateSub(l
, ConstantInt::get(T
, 1),
219 new StoreInst(nv
, Counter
, t
);
223 BasicBlock
* oldnext
= t
->getSuccessor(0);
224 BasicBlock
* resetblock
= BasicBlock::Create("reset", oldnext
->getParent(),
226 TerminatorInst
* t2
= BranchInst::Create(oldnext
, resetblock
);
227 t
->setSuccessor(0, resetblock
);
228 new StoreInst(ResetValue
, Counter
, t2
);
229 ReplacePhiPred(oldnext
, bb
, resetblock
);
232 GlobalRandomCounterOpt::GlobalRandomCounterOpt(Module
& M
, const Type
* t
,
235 ConstantInt
* Init
= ConstantInt::get(T
, resetval
);
237 Counter
= new GlobalVariable(T
, false, GlobalValue::InternalLinkage
,
238 Init
, "RandomSteeringCounter", &M
);
241 GlobalRandomCounterOpt::~GlobalRandomCounterOpt() {}
243 void GlobalRandomCounterOpt::PrepFunction(Function
* F
) {
244 //make a local temporary to cache the global
245 BasicBlock
& bb
= F
->getEntryBlock();
246 BasicBlock::iterator InsertPt
= bb
.begin();
247 AI
= new AllocaInst(T
, 0, "localcounter", InsertPt
);
248 LoadInst
* l
= new LoadInst(Counter
, "counterload", InsertPt
);
249 new StoreInst(l
, AI
, InsertPt
);
251 //modify all functions and return values to restore the local variable to/from
252 //the global variable
253 for(Function::iterator fib
= F
->begin(), fie
= F
->end();
255 for(BasicBlock::iterator bib
= fib
->begin(), bie
= fib
->end();
257 if (isa
<CallInst
>(bib
)) {
258 LoadInst
* l
= new LoadInst(AI
, "counter", bib
);
259 new StoreInst(l
, Counter
, bib
);
260 l
= new LoadInst(Counter
, "counter", ++bib
);
261 new StoreInst(l
, AI
, bib
--);
262 } else if (isa
<InvokeInst
>(bib
)) {
263 LoadInst
* l
= new LoadInst(AI
, "counter", bib
);
264 new StoreInst(l
, Counter
, bib
);
266 BasicBlock
* bb
= cast
<InvokeInst
>(bib
)->getNormalDest();
267 BasicBlock::iterator i
= bb
->getFirstNonPHI();
268 l
= new LoadInst(Counter
, "counter", i
);
270 bb
= cast
<InvokeInst
>(bib
)->getUnwindDest();
271 i
= bb
->getFirstNonPHI();
272 l
= new LoadInst(Counter
, "counter", i
);
273 new StoreInst(l
, AI
, i
);
274 } else if (isa
<UnwindInst
>(&*bib
) || isa
<ReturnInst
>(&*bib
)) {
275 LoadInst
* l
= new LoadInst(AI
, "counter", bib
);
276 new StoreInst(l
, Counter
, bib
);
280 void GlobalRandomCounterOpt::ProcessChoicePoint(BasicBlock
* bb
) {
281 BranchInst
* t
= cast
<BranchInst
>(bb
->getTerminator());
284 LoadInst
* l
= new LoadInst(AI
, "counter", t
);
286 ICmpInst
* s
= new ICmpInst(ICmpInst::ICMP_EQ
, l
, ConstantInt::get(T
, 0),
289 Value
* nv
= BinaryOperator::CreateSub(l
, ConstantInt::get(T
, 1),
291 new StoreInst(nv
, AI
, t
);
295 BasicBlock
* oldnext
= t
->getSuccessor(0);
296 BasicBlock
* resetblock
= BasicBlock::Create("reset", oldnext
->getParent(),
298 TerminatorInst
* t2
= BranchInst::Create(oldnext
, resetblock
);
299 t
->setSuccessor(0, resetblock
);
300 new StoreInst(ResetValue
, AI
, t2
);
301 ReplacePhiPred(oldnext
, bb
, resetblock
);
305 CycleCounter::CycleCounter(Module
& m
, uint64_t resetmask
) : rm(resetmask
) {
306 F
= Intrinsic::getDeclaration(&m
, Intrinsic::readcyclecounter
);
309 CycleCounter::~CycleCounter() {}
311 void CycleCounter::PrepFunction(Function
* F
) {}
313 void CycleCounter::ProcessChoicePoint(BasicBlock
* bb
) {
314 BranchInst
* t
= cast
<BranchInst
>(bb
->getTerminator());
316 CallInst
* c
= CallInst::Create(F
, "rdcc", t
);
318 BinaryOperator::CreateAnd(c
, ConstantInt::get(Type::Int64Ty
, rm
),
321 ICmpInst
*s
= new ICmpInst(ICmpInst::ICMP_EQ
, b
,
322 ConstantInt::get(Type::Int64Ty
, 0),
328 ///////////////////////////////////////
330 ///////////////////////////////////////
331 bool RSProfilers_std::isProfiling(Value
* v
) {
332 if (profcode
.find(v
) != profcode
.end())
335 RSProfilers
& LI
= getAnalysis
<RSProfilers
>();
336 return LI
.isProfiling(v
);
339 void RSProfilers_std::IncrementCounterInBlock(BasicBlock
*BB
, unsigned CounterNum
,
340 GlobalValue
*CounterArray
) {
341 // Insert the increment after any alloca or PHI instructions...
342 BasicBlock::iterator InsertPos
= BB
->getFirstNonPHI();
343 while (isa
<AllocaInst
>(InsertPos
))
346 // Create the getelementptr constant expression
347 std::vector
<Constant
*> Indices(2);
348 Indices
[0] = Constant::getNullValue(Type::Int32Ty
);
349 Indices
[1] = ConstantInt::get(Type::Int32Ty
, CounterNum
);
350 Constant
*ElementPtr
= ConstantExpr::getGetElementPtr(CounterArray
,
353 // Load, increment and store the value back.
354 Value
*OldVal
= new LoadInst(ElementPtr
, "OldCounter", InsertPos
);
355 profcode
.insert(OldVal
);
356 Value
*NewVal
= BinaryOperator::CreateAdd(OldVal
,
357 ConstantInt::get(Type::Int32Ty
, 1),
358 "NewCounter", InsertPos
);
359 profcode
.insert(NewVal
);
360 profcode
.insert(new StoreInst(NewVal
, ElementPtr
, InsertPos
));
363 void RSProfilers_std::getAnalysisUsage(AnalysisUsage
&AU
) const {
364 //grab any outstanding profiler, or get the null one
365 AU
.addRequired
<RSProfilers
>();
368 ///////////////////////////////////////
370 ///////////////////////////////////////
372 Value
* ProfilerRS::Translate(Value
* v
) {
374 return TransCache
[v
];
376 if (BasicBlock
* bb
= dyn_cast
<BasicBlock
>(v
)) {
377 if (bb
== &bb
->getParent()->getEntryBlock())
378 TransCache
[bb
] = bb
; //don't translate entry block
380 TransCache
[bb
] = BasicBlock::Create("dup_" + bb
->getName(),
381 bb
->getParent(), NULL
);
382 return TransCache
[bb
];
383 } else if (Instruction
* i
= dyn_cast
<Instruction
>(v
)) {
384 //we have already translated this
385 //do not translate entry block allocas
386 if(&i
->getParent()->getParent()->getEntryBlock() == i
->getParent()) {
391 Instruction
* i2
= i
->clone();
393 i2
->setName("dup_" + i
->getName());
396 for (unsigned x
= 0; x
< i2
->getNumOperands(); ++x
)
397 i2
->setOperand(x
, Translate(i2
->getOperand(x
)));
400 } else if (isa
<Function
>(v
) || isa
<Constant
>(v
) || isa
<Argument
>(v
)) {
404 assert(0 && "Value not handled");
408 void ProfilerRS::Duplicate(Function
& F
, RSProfilers
& LI
)
410 //perform a breadth first search, building up a duplicate of the code
411 std::queue
<BasicBlock
*> worklist
;
412 std::set
<BasicBlock
*> seen
;
414 //This loop ensures proper BB order, to help performance
415 for (Function::iterator fib
= F
.begin(), fie
= F
.end(); fib
!= fie
; ++fib
)
417 while (!worklist
.empty()) {
418 Translate(worklist
.front());
422 //remember than reg2mem created a new entry block we don't want to duplicate
423 worklist
.push(F
.getEntryBlock().getTerminator()->getSuccessor(0));
424 seen
.insert(&F
.getEntryBlock());
426 while (!worklist
.empty()) {
427 BasicBlock
* bb
= worklist
.front();
429 if(seen
.find(bb
) == seen
.end()) {
430 BasicBlock
* bbtarget
= cast
<BasicBlock
>(Translate(bb
));
431 BasicBlock::InstListType
& instlist
= bbtarget
->getInstList();
432 for (BasicBlock::iterator iib
= bb
->begin(), iie
= bb
->end();
435 if (!LI
.isProfiling(&*iib
)) {
436 Instruction
* i
= cast
<Instruction
>(Translate(iib
));
437 instlist
.insert(bbtarget
->end(), i
);
440 //updated search state;
442 TerminatorInst
* ti
= bb
->getTerminator();
443 for (unsigned x
= 0; x
< ti
->getNumSuccessors(); ++x
) {
444 BasicBlock
* bbs
= ti
->getSuccessor(x
);
445 if (seen
.find(bbs
) == seen
.end()) {
453 void ProfilerRS::ProcessBackEdge(BasicBlock
* src
, BasicBlock
* dst
, Function
& F
) {
454 //given a backedge from B -> A, and translations A' and B',
456 //b: add branches in C to A and A' and in C' to A and A'
457 //c: mod terminators@B, replace A with C
458 //d: mod terminators@B', replace A' with C'
459 //e: mod phis@A for pred B to be pred C
460 // if multiple entries, simplify to one
461 //f: mod phis@A' for pred B' to be pred C'
462 // if multiple entries, simplify to one
463 //g: for all phis@A with pred C using x
464 // add in edge from C' using x'
465 // add in edge from C using x in A'
468 Function::iterator BBN
= src
; ++BBN
;
469 BasicBlock
* bbC
= BasicBlock::Create("choice", &F
, BBN
);
470 //ChoicePoints.insert(bbC);
471 BBN
= cast
<BasicBlock
>(Translate(src
));
472 BasicBlock
* bbCp
= BasicBlock::Create("choice", &F
, ++BBN
);
473 ChoicePoints
.insert(bbCp
);
476 BranchInst::Create(cast
<BasicBlock
>(Translate(dst
)), bbC
);
477 BranchInst::Create(dst
, cast
<BasicBlock
>(Translate(dst
)),
478 ConstantInt::get(Type::Int1Ty
, true), bbCp
);
481 TerminatorInst
* iB
= src
->getTerminator();
482 for (unsigned x
= 0; x
< iB
->getNumSuccessors(); ++x
)
483 if (iB
->getSuccessor(x
) == dst
)
484 iB
->setSuccessor(x
, bbC
);
488 TerminatorInst
* iBp
= cast
<TerminatorInst
>(Translate(src
->getTerminator()));
489 for (unsigned x
= 0; x
< iBp
->getNumSuccessors(); ++x
)
490 if (iBp
->getSuccessor(x
) == cast
<BasicBlock
>(Translate(dst
)))
491 iBp
->setSuccessor(x
, bbCp
);
494 ReplacePhiPred(dst
, src
, bbC
);
495 //src could be a switch, in which case we are replacing several edges with one
496 //thus collapse those edges int the Phi
497 CollapsePhi(dst
, bbC
);
499 ReplacePhiPred(cast
<BasicBlock
>(Translate(dst
)),
500 cast
<BasicBlock
>(Translate(src
)),bbCp
);
501 CollapsePhi(cast
<BasicBlock
>(Translate(dst
)), bbCp
);
503 for(BasicBlock::iterator ib
= dst
->begin(), ie
= dst
->end(); ib
!= ie
;
505 if (PHINode
* phi
= dyn_cast
<PHINode
>(&*ib
)) {
506 for(unsigned x
= 0; x
< phi
->getNumIncomingValues(); ++x
)
507 if(bbC
== phi
->getIncomingBlock(x
)) {
508 phi
->addIncoming(Translate(phi
->getIncomingValue(x
)), bbCp
);
509 cast
<PHINode
>(Translate(phi
))->addIncoming(phi
->getIncomingValue(x
),
512 phi
->removeIncomingValue(bbC
);
516 bool ProfilerRS::runOnFunction(Function
& F
) {
517 if (!F
.isDeclaration()) {
518 std::set
<std::pair
<BasicBlock
*, BasicBlock
*> > BackEdges
;
519 RSProfilers
& LI
= getAnalysis
<RSProfilers
>();
521 getBackEdges(F
, BackEdges
);
523 //assume that stuff worked. now connect the duplicated basic blocks
524 //with the originals in such a way as to preserve ssa. yuk!
525 for (std::set
<std::pair
<BasicBlock
*, BasicBlock
*> >::iterator
526 ib
= BackEdges
.begin(), ie
= BackEdges
.end(); ib
!= ie
; ++ib
)
527 ProcessBackEdge(ib
->first
, ib
->second
, F
);
529 //oh, and add the edge from the reg2mem created entry node to the
530 //duplicated second node
531 TerminatorInst
* T
= F
.getEntryBlock().getTerminator();
532 ReplaceInstWithInst(T
, BranchInst::Create(T
->getSuccessor(0),
534 Translate(T
->getSuccessor(0))),
535 ConstantInt::get(Type::Int1Ty
,
538 //do whatever is needed now that the function is duplicated
541 //add entry node to choice points
542 ChoicePoints
.insert(&F
.getEntryBlock());
544 for (std::set
<BasicBlock
*>::iterator
545 ii
= ChoicePoints
.begin(), ie
= ChoicePoints
.end(); ii
!= ie
; ++ii
)
546 c
->ProcessChoicePoint(*ii
);
548 ChoicePoints
.clear();
556 bool ProfilerRS::doInitialization(Module
&M
) {
557 switch (RandomMethod
) {
559 c
= new GlobalRandomCounter(M
, Type::Int32Ty
, (1 << 14) - 1);
562 c
= new GlobalRandomCounterOpt(M
, Type::Int32Ty
, (1 << 14) - 1);
565 c
= new CycleCounter(M
, (1 << 14) - 1);
571 void ProfilerRS::getAnalysisUsage(AnalysisUsage
&AU
) const {
572 AU
.addRequired
<RSProfilers
>();
573 AU
.addRequiredID(DemoteRegisterToMemoryID
);
576 ///////////////////////////////////////
578 ///////////////////////////////////////
579 static void ReplacePhiPred(BasicBlock
* btarget
,
580 BasicBlock
* bold
, BasicBlock
* bnew
) {
581 for(BasicBlock::iterator ib
= btarget
->begin(), ie
= btarget
->end();
583 if (PHINode
* phi
= dyn_cast
<PHINode
>(&*ib
)) {
584 for(unsigned x
= 0; x
< phi
->getNumIncomingValues(); ++x
)
585 if(bold
== phi
->getIncomingBlock(x
))
586 phi
->setIncomingBlock(x
, bnew
);
590 static void CollapsePhi(BasicBlock
* btarget
, BasicBlock
* bsrc
) {
591 for(BasicBlock::iterator ib
= btarget
->begin(), ie
= btarget
->end();
593 if (PHINode
* phi
= dyn_cast
<PHINode
>(&*ib
)) {
594 std::map
<BasicBlock
*, Value
*> counter
;
595 for(unsigned i
= 0; i
< phi
->getNumIncomingValues(); ) {
596 if (counter
[phi
->getIncomingBlock(i
)]) {
597 assert(phi
->getIncomingValue(i
) == counter
[phi
->getIncomingBlock(i
)]);
598 phi
->removeIncomingValue(i
, false);
600 counter
[phi
->getIncomingBlock(i
)] = phi
->getIncomingValue(i
);
608 static void recBackEdge(BasicBlock
* bb
, T
& BackEdges
,
609 std::map
<BasicBlock
*, int>& color
,
610 std::map
<BasicBlock
*, int>& depth
,
611 std::map
<BasicBlock
*, int>& finish
,
617 TerminatorInst
* t
= bb
->getTerminator();
618 for(unsigned i
= 0; i
< t
->getNumSuccessors(); ++i
) {
619 BasicBlock
* bbnew
= t
->getSuccessor(i
);
620 if (color
[bbnew
] == 0)
621 recBackEdge(bbnew
, BackEdges
, color
, depth
, finish
, time
);
622 else if (color
[bbnew
] == 1) {
623 BackEdges
.insert(std::make_pair(bb
, bbnew
));
634 //find the back edges and where they go to
636 static void getBackEdges(Function
& F
, T
& BackEdges
) {
637 std::map
<BasicBlock
*, int> color
;
638 std::map
<BasicBlock
*, int> depth
;
639 std::map
<BasicBlock
*, int> finish
;
641 recBackEdge(&F
.getEntryBlock(), BackEdges
, color
, depth
, finish
, time
);
642 DOUT
<< F
.getName() << " " << BackEdges
.size() << "\n";
647 ModulePass
* llvm::createNullProfilerRSPass() {
648 return new NullProfilerRS();
651 FunctionPass
* llvm::createRSProfilingPass() {
652 return new ProfilerRS();